From MeritBadgeDotOrg

Jump to: navigation, search
This is the Discussion page for discussing improvements to the associated article.
Please place messages concerning errors or requested changes to the protected portions of the article on this Discussion page.
This is not a forum for general discussion of the article's subject.
Articles have been created following a common format for all Merit Badges. Please help keep these articles in this format and help us add links to related requirements for other awards and external requirement resources.
Answers, answer keys, cheat sheets, or links to them will be removed.
When posting on this or any Discussion page:  
  • Put new text under old text. Click here to start a new topic.
  • Please sign and date your posts by typing four tildes (~~~~).

  • Please familiarize yourself with Help:Talk pages before posting on discussion (a.k.a. talk) pages.
    — Use headings, indentations; and please, always sign (~~~~) your posts. (See Help:Talk pages for details.)
    — Ask your Scouting/advancement-related questions on our forums... several Scouters will be happy to help you.

    Microsoft Encarta link

    Via message from Wagionvigil:

    One of the links on the Electricity merit badge page points to an encarta article with bad advice for reducing the risk from a lightning strike.


    The article advises correctly to:

    • Avoid trees
    • Take shelter in a car

    and incorrectly to:

    • Lie flat on the ground

    This bad advice is based on the idea that you are less of a target for a direct lightning strike by staying low to the ground. While this is true, there is little to be gained between lying flat and squatting. However, by lying flat you insert your body as a parallel conductor in the any ground surface currents from a nearby lightning strike. Being near a lightning strike is much more likely than being directly hit with lightning.

    Because the energy in lightning is so high, typically currents in the ten's of thousands to hundreds of thousands of Amperes are developed. This current largely dissipates across the surface of the earth. Because the currents are so high the potential difference across the dimension of a human body is more than sufficient to develop a lethal current and induce heart failure.

    The better advice is to squat on the balls of your feet on an insulated surface such as a life jacket or doubled up sleeping pad. Keep your feet close together and avoid touching the ground with your hands. By squatting, you also reduce the possibility of a direct strike without increasing your risk from a nearby strike.

    If you are in a group, spread out so that risks from a very near strike are minimized, and the possibility of survivors being able to assist any injured is maximized. Avoid trees as they are a likely target for a strike and bring the lightning current into close proximity to all nearby. --Wagionvigil

    Resovled. (Special thanks to Sysop Milominderbinder2 for the new links.) —RWSmith (Bureaucrat), 14:31, February 25, 2009 (EST)

    Follow-up note

    By the way, I contacted Micorsoft Encarta about the bad info and provided Wagionvigil's correct info shown above. —RWSmith (Bureaucrat), 14:34, February 25, 2009 (EST)

    Personal tools