Talk:Fishing

From MeritBadgeDotOrg

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
(New page: {{Merit Badge Talk page header}})
Current revision (12:51, April 17, 2013) (edit) (undo)
(Problem with requirement #4: new section)
 
Line 1: Line 1:
{{Merit Badge Talk page header}}
{{Merit Badge Talk page header}}
 +
 +
== Problem with requirement #4 ==
 +
 +
Requirement #4 has a scout demonstrating various knots.
 +
The one in question is "bloop loop (barrel knot)"
 +
 +
These are two different knots.
 +
One is a "loop" formed in the middle of a line to attach additional lures, weights, bait, etc. to.
 +
The other is a "bend", joining two lines.
 +
 +
The more currently common name for the Blood Loop is the Drooper Loop. You'll find this designation all over the internet and a animatedknots.com.
 +
 +
The "Barrel Knot" is also called the "Blood Knot" which is where I think someone got confused, thinking "blood knot" and "bloop loop" were the same thing.
 +
 +
The other issue is, the Fishing MB book shows and describes the "barrel knot" yet they still call it a loop, which it doesn't have.
 +
 +
It seems like the MB requirement intended to have the "blood loop" since all other knots listed in Requirement 4 are loops. The blood loop is similar to the blood knot (which is also called the barrel knot) and somewhere down the line, the "typo" was made.
 +
 +
(Personally, I'd think joining two fishing lines might be a good fishing skill to have, but is beyond the basics of a Merit Badge course.)

Current revision

Image:2230c.gif
This is the Discussion page for discussing improvements to the associated article.
Please place messages concerning errors or requested changes to the protected portions of the article on this Discussion page.
This is not a forum for general discussion of the article's subject.
Articles have been created following a common format for all Merit Badges. Please help keep these articles in this format and help us add links to related requirements for other awards and external requirement resources.
Answers, answer keys, cheat sheets, or links to them will be removed.
When posting on this or any Discussion page:  
  • Put new text under old text. Click here to start a new topic.
  • Please sign and date your posts by typing four tildes (~~~~).

  • Problem with requirement #4

    Requirement #4 has a scout demonstrating various knots. The one in question is "bloop loop (barrel knot)"

    These are two different knots. One is a "loop" formed in the middle of a line to attach additional lures, weights, bait, etc. to. The other is a "bend", joining two lines.

    The more currently common name for the Blood Loop is the Drooper Loop. You'll find this designation all over the internet and a animatedknots.com.

    The "Barrel Knot" is also called the "Blood Knot" which is where I think someone got confused, thinking "blood knot" and "bloop loop" were the same thing.

    The other issue is, the Fishing MB book shows and describes the "barrel knot" yet they still call it a loop, which it doesn't have.

    It seems like the MB requirement intended to have the "blood loop" since all other knots listed in Requirement 4 are loops. The blood loop is similar to the blood knot (which is also called the barrel knot) and somewhere down the line, the "typo" was made.

    (Personally, I'd think joining two fishing lines might be a good fishing skill to have, but is beyond the basics of a Merit Badge course.)

    Personal tools
    language